What To Put on a Baby Registry for Your Second Baby

Welcome to round two. You’ve done the blowouts, the bottle-washing marathons, the 3 a.m. Googling. You’ve lived it. So why does it still feel like your brain is short-circuiting trying to figure out what to put on a baby registry for your second baby?

The truth is, a second baby registry doesn’t need to be a copy-paste of the first. You’re not the same parent, and this baby isn’t the same either. A well-planned second time mom baby registry is less about the latest trending gear and more about reclaiming your sanity with smart, strategic choices.

Below, we’ve rounded up second baby registry ideas that are actually useful, starting with tried-and-true essential. 

Baby Gear You’ll Actually Use Again

Double stroller: If your kids will be close in age, a double stroller is a must. The bēbee twin lightweight double stroller from Bombi makes venturing out with two little ones manageable, not maddening. It’s easy to fold, compact, and lightware. If your first is already more independent or stroller-free, the bēbee v2 lightweight stroller might still be the right call for your second go-round.

Convertible car seat: Grab one that grows with your child to make things easier this time. The Chicco Fit360 or something similar will last from infancy through booster stage. And the rotating base is a game-changer!

Baby carrier: If you didn’t love your wrap the first time (no judgment), go for a structured, breathable option like the Ergobaby Mesh Carrier. Lightweight, adjustable, and actually doable with a toddler in tow.

Feeding Upgrades & Repeats

New bottles and nipples: Even if you saved them from round one, bottle nipples wear down and can harbor bacteria. Time for a fresh set. We love Nuk Simply Natural for combo feeding.

Sterilizer: If you skipped this the first time, add it now. The First Years Modular Steam Sterilizer will save you from late-night boiling marathons.

Burp cloths and bibs: These go fast and get gross even faster. Stock up on fresh muslin burp cloths and snag some cute bibs (we love Konny Baby for their drool-worthy style and absorbency).

Nursing pillow: Did it get squashed into a sad pancake last time? Happens to the best of us. Grab a new one from Momcozy that supports feeding and tummy time.

Sleep, Bath, and Diapering Do-Overs

Monitor upgrade: If yours was a glitchy mess, consider a Nanit or similar with video and insights that won’t drive you nuts.

Swaddles: Even if you loved them, elastics wear out and fabric stretches. The Ollie Swaddle is a go-to for sleep-deprived, one-handed nighttime wrapping.

Ointments and creams: Babies love a fresh tub of Tubby Todd All Over Ointment. Trust us.

Wipes and accessories: Restock the WaterWipes, pick up a fresh Bum Brush, and don’t forget tools like the Oogiebear or haakaa nail file to make cleanup quick and painless.

Bath gear: A hooded towel that’s still fluffy? Probably not. We love KeaBabies for softness and absorbency.

Small But Mighty Sanity Savers

Night lights: A portable, soft-glow nightlight will save your shins and your sanity during middle-of-the-night feedings and diaper changes.

Stain spray: Miss Mouth’s Messy Eater Spray is the unsung hero of laundry day. Great for clothes, sheets, and your own sanity.

Bath kneeler: Not essential, but your knees will thank you. Skip Hop makes a good one.

What Can Be Skipped In Your Registry For Second Baby 

• Wipe warmers. Not worth the space.

• Fancy toys. A few are fine, but babies are mostly into you.

• Button-up PJs. Zippers or magnetic closures are the only answer during 2 a.m. changes.

• Wrap carriers that require a YouTube tutorial.

Answering Your Second Baby Registry Questions

Is it selfish to create a baby registry for second baby?
Nope. People want to celebrate your growing family. A registry isn’t a demand! It’s a guide. Think of it as a helpful list, not a gift grab.

Do people make a baby registry for the second baby?
Definitely. While your first registry may have covered everything, this one is more practical. Focus on what’s worn out, what needs doubling, and what will make your life easier this time around.

What do you need on a registry for a second baby?
Think replacements, refreshes, and sanity savers. Add anything that was well-loved (and well-used) by your firstborn, plus new gear to make life with two feel manageable.

Considerations before you build your second baby registry:

• Age gap: Will your kids need to share gear or will your oldest be phasing out of it?

• Storage: Be honest about how much space you have.

• Lifestyle changes: New home? New schedule? New daycare plan? Build accordingly.

The Bottom Line on Your Second Baby Registry

Creating a baby registry for a second baby isn’t just allowed - it’s encouraged. You’ve got new needs, better instincts, and maybe a little less time. A thoughtful, streamlined registry helps friends and family support you in ways that actually make a difference.

From double strollers to new swaddles, these registry items for a second baby are all about keeping things simple, smart, and totally stress-reducing. And if you're looking for strollers that go the distance (and still fit through doorways), Bombi's bēbee v2 and bēbee twin should be at the top of your list.